02
The NCAA's Next Big Problem? Peptides and Artificial Intelligence.
College athletics is changing faster than the rules can keep up. I think two of the biggest challenges ahead are ones we're only beginning to understand.
By Elle LaFontan | October 2026
For years, the biggest conversations surrounding NCAA violations have revolved around recruiting, illegal benefits, performance-enhancing drugs, and, more recently, NIL.. But I think the next wave of controversy in college athletics will look different. It won't necessarily involve the traditional scandals we've grown used to seeing. I think peptides and artificial intelligence are going to create some of the NCAA's most complicated problems yet. And the interesting part? They're both emerging at a time when college athletics is already struggling to define what is fair, what is legal, and what gives an athlete an advantage.
Peptides: The New Gray Area in Performance Enhancement
As a Division I athlete, I know how much time and effort goes into training, recovery, and staying healthy enough to compete. Athletes are constantly looking for ways to recover faster, prevent injuries, and improve their performance. Recently, peptides have become an increasingly visible part of the broader fitness and wellness conversation. Substances such as BPC-157 and TB-500 are often marketed online with claims about injury recovery and tissue repair. However, research supporting many of these claims in humans remains limited, and these substances are prohibited under NCAA rules. The NCAA already bans classes of peptide hormones, growth factors, and related substances, and its testing program includes these classes. So the issue isn't necessarily that the NCAA has no rules. It's that the popularity and marketing of these products can move faster than athletes' understanding of those rules. A substance can be promoted as a recovery tool, wellness product, or medical innovation while still being prohibited in college athletics.
That's where I think the next major controversy could begin. Imagine an athlete recovering from a serious injury who encounters a product online promising faster healing. They might see influencers promoting it, hear about it from people outside their athletic department, and assume it's safe because it's widely available. But availability doesn't equal approval. I think this raises a bigger question: Where is the line between legitimate medical recovery and an unfair competitive advantage? The NCAA needs to continue educating athletes about these distinctions as new substances become more widely marketed.
02-Artificial Intelligence: A Different Kind of Competitive Advantage
AI presents a completely different challenge. Unlike performance-enhancing substances, artificial intelligence isn't inherently prohibited in college sports. In fact, it already offers valuable opportunities for athletic programs. AI can help with analyzing game footage, identifying patterns, optimizing training, producing marketing content, and improving communication. But as AI becomes more advanced, I think the NCAA will face questions that existing regulations weren't designed to answer. What happens when one athletic program has access to significantly more advanced predictive technology than another? How should schools handle AI-generated recruiting communications or promotional content? What happens when an athlete's face, voice, or identity is replicated without permission? And how do we distinguish legitimate technological innovation from manipulation? The most concerning uses of AI might not even happen on the field. They could emerge through NIL, recruiting, athlete representation, and the rapid spread of realistic but fabricated media. For a generation of student-athletes whose personal brands now carry real financial value, digital identity is becoming something worth protecting. Two Different Innovations, One Bigger Question. Peptides and AI might sound like completely unrelated topics, but I think they share something important. Both are developing in environments where the potential benefits are exciting, the risks aren't always obvious, and regulation is struggling to keep pace with innovation. And neither issue can be solved simply by telling athletes to avoid new technology. AI has legitimate applications that can make athletics better. Medical research may eventually create new, evidence-based treatments that improve recovery and athlete health. The challenge is understanding how to use innovation responsibly without compromising safety or competitive fairness.
My Prediction
I don't think the next era of NCAA controversy will only be about athletes breaking rules they already understand. I think it will increasingly involve situations where the technology, science, and commercial incentives have moved ahead of the rules themselves. The NCAA's next big challenge won't just be policing athletes. It will be defining what fair competition looks like in a world where the definition of an advantage is constantly changing.
And I think we're only seeing the beginning.